INVITATION TO HEX DIGITAL CULTURES SEMINAR SERIES:
WHO Patrick T. Gavin and Ahmad M. Kamal, Faculty of Media and Information, University of Western Ontario, London, Kanada
WHAT: At the Confluence of Ideologies: Social Media, Sustained Critique
Abstract: Foucault argued that “the work of deep transformation can only be carried out in a free atmosphere, one constantly agitated by a permanent criticism” (1988, 155). This “permanent criticism” is necessary because a “transformation that remains within the same mode of thought, a transformation that is only a way of adjusting the same thought more closely to the reality of things can merely be a superficial transformation” (155). The potential to realize “deep transformation” through the use of social media therefore necessitates a permanent critique of the technology’s various underlying ideologies. In this paper, we focus our critique on three specific ideologies that converge in many studies – whether celebratory or critical – of social media and its political efficacy: information, civil society, and democracy. We chose these three because they respectively presuppose what social media is about, whom it is for, and what it might accomplish.
The work of Day (2001a; 2001b; 2008) and Peters (1988) on the ideology of information demonstrate how capitalist, epistemological, liberal, and technocratic values are mobilized through a historical notion of information that acts as a totalizing, self-legitimizing trope. Information becomes at once an extensive yet narrow imperative colonizing social interaction and individual cognition. Dunn’s work on the ideology of democracy (2005, 2010) raises critique above the perennial debate over democracy’s best model (e.g., direct, deliberative, republican) by recognizing that democracy’s recent ascendancy as a political and rhetorical prerogative is contingent on its highly equivocal nature. Given democracy’s ambiguity, Post (2006) has argued that democracy is too shallow an ideology to redress the many injustices its proponents expect it to resolve, while Wood (2006) contends that it serves as ideological weapon for neo-imperialism. The ideology of democracy is arguably a detour on the path to social welfare and equality. The ideology of civil society underwrites both information networks and genuine democracy. Ehrenberg (1999) demonstrates its convoluted history and shakes it free of many celebratory assumptions. Perhaps most significantly, Ehrenberg reveals civil society as complicit in liberal policy. Meanwhile, the work of Mansbridge (1980) suggests that an overestimation of civil society obscures local exercises of coercion and exploitation.
Despite the importance of the aforementioned studies, they suffer drawbacks we hope to rectify. First, these analyses are usually done in isolation despite the interconnectedness of the concepts. Second, these studies either predate or ignore the introduction of new media, raising the question whether social media has since transformed these ideologies so as to require re-evaluation of the critiques of Day, Dunn, or Ehrenberg. Third, despite posing powerful rebuttals to the vaunted power of information, democracy, and civil society, the studies we draw upon have received limited uptake in popular, academic, and critical discourse. Bringing together all of these critiques in the present discussion on social media’s socio-political possibilities is important. It allows us to begin systematically unpacking the ideals that are now interwoven in both the rhetoric of “Facebook Revolutions,” “Twitter Uprisings,” and “Democracy 2.0,” and the more nuanced evaluations of social media’s transformative efficacy. By revisiting the critical analyses above we endeavor to engage in Foucault’s permanent critique, and thereby continue to scrutinize the assumptions in political discourse in the 21st century.
WHEN? April 27, 13.15–15
WHERE? Department of Arts and Cultural Sciences, Lund. Room 202, 1st floor, in Kulturanatomen at Biskopsgatan 7.
If you have any questions conserning the seminar, please contact hanna.carlsson@kultur.lu.se
Welcome!
Posted under Aktiviteter
This post was written by HannaC on April 2, 2012






Den 15 april arrangerar HEX en öppen föreläsning med tillhörande workshop, och det handlar om TV:
